The Russians were not the only ones in the early 1990s who did not like the idea of NATO enlargement. A written document, according to the German daily Spiegel, was “extracted” from the British national archives by the American political scientist Joshua Shifrinson, a professor at Boston University. From CNN's Radina Gigova in Atlanta And the new member states all enjoy that very same guarantee. There were critics at the time that Naito was expanding to the Baltics. Meeting with Russian President Mikhail Gorbachev (left), in Moscow on February 9, 1990, U.S. Secretary of State James Baker III (right) admitted that NATO was the mechanism for maintaining U.S. military presence in Europe. A newly discovered document provides more evidence that Western governments broke their promise not to expand NATO eastward after German reunification. So what? Did NATO break their promise to Russia, never to expand a single inch east?. In 1990, few gave the possibility of a broader NATO enlargement to the east any serious thought. Notes from a 1991 meeting between top US, British, French, and German officials confirm that there was a “general agreement that membership of NATO and security guarantees [are] unacceptable” for Central … Europe NATO: Why Russia has a problem with its eastward expansion. ... “Any possible integration of … Claim : NATO Promised Not To Expand A Single Inch East! A British representative also mentions the existence of a “general agreement” that membership of NATO for eastern European countries is “unacceptable.” In 1990, during the negotiations over the unification of West and East Germany, and then, again, in 1993, when NATO was extending its Partnership for Peace policy eastward. ... “Any possible integration of … The Soviet Union collapsed a year later, but an agreement between NATO and Russia that the military bloc would not expand to the east is a “myth”, political analysts say. Did NATO promise Russia not to expand a single inch east, into former Warsaw Pact countries like Poland, or former Soviet Union countries like Ukraine? Russia insists that there was an agreement not to expand Nato eastwards after the end of the USSR. But NATO has long insisted it has an open … So what? Russia insists that there was an agreement not to expand Nato eastwards after the end of the USSR. NATO’s door has been open to new members since it was founded in 1949 – and that has never changed. During his annual press conference on December 23, 2021, Vladimir Putin directly accused NATO of lying. Memories conflict as to whether the U.S. had promised him that NATO would not expand into former Soviet territory. Thus, in this conversation, the U.S. secretary of state three times offers assurances that if Germany were allowed to unify in NATO, preserving the U.S. presence in Europe, then NATO would not expand to the east. Claim : NATO Promised Not To Expand A Single Inch East! Vladimir Putin's press conference / AP “This is a myth. Of course, the decision to expand NATO in the post-Cold War world was a very controversial decision. “Not an inch to the east,” we were told in the 1990s. This document shows that James Baker repeatedly assured Gorbachev that the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) would not expand. In 1994, Russia joined the Partnership for Peace program, and through the early-2010s, NATO and Russia signed several additional agreements on cooperation.. The Soviet Union collapsed a year later, but an agreement between NATO and Russia that the military bloc would not expand to the east is a “myth”, political analysts say. Did NATO promise Russia not to expand a single inch east, into former Warsaw Pact countries like Poland, or former Soviet Union countries like Ukraine?. Did NATO break that … In both cases, the assurances were given by US secretaries of state, James Baker… The agreement said nothing about NATO’s ability to expand farther east, a process that began with the admission of Poland, the Czech Republic and Hungary as members in 1999. Memories conflict as to whether the U.S. had promised him that NATO would not expand into former Soviet territory. Thus, again, what seems clear is that there was at least a joint assumption and informal agreement that NATO would not expand to the east beyond the GDR. Michael Rühle takes on the myths and realities of the Russian narrative. Chatham House Lies about ‘Aggressor Russia’ Exposed: NATO Did Promise Not to Expand East. From CNN's Radina Gigova in Atlanta It currently spends less than one per cent of GDP on defence, which ranks it 23rd among 28 NATO members. 10:54 a.m. Notes from a 1991 meeting between top US, British, French, and German officials confirm that there was a “general agreement that membership of NATO and security guarantees [are] unacceptable” for … After its Soviet enemy crumbled, NATO kept growing. A British representative also mentions the existence of a “general agreement” that membership of NATO for eastern European countries is “unacceptable.” Take a look at the claim, and find out what the facts really are! Did NATO break that promise? The document … Despite their denials, Western leaders did make a promise to the USSR that NATO would not expand to Central and Eastern Europe when Moscow agreed to Germany’s reunification, Willy Wimmer, a former vice president of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), has claimed in an interview with RT on Saturday. Despite their denials, Western leaders did make a promise to the USSR that NATO would not expand to Central and Eastern Europe when Moscow agreed to Germany’s reunification, Willy Wimmer, a former vice president of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), has claimed in an interview with RT on Saturday. That is what Russian President Vladimir Putin has been claiming since 2007, and is … There have been several claims that there was an agreement between NATO and USSR at the end of the Cold War. But Article 5 endures to this day. Claim: NATO promised Russia it would not expand after the Cold War Fact : Such an agreement was never made. After the collapse of the Warsaw bloc, NATO made promises that they would not expand to the East. Answer (1 of 13): Actually, no such promised was ever made and, as others here have pointed out, the former Soviet Bloc countries themselves sought out NATO membership. NATO twice made a promise to Russia that it would not expand eastward. “NATO should not expand to the east, either officially or unofficially,” Seitz added. Putin claims that Baker, in a discussion on 9 February 1990 with the Soviet leader, Mikhail Gorbachev, made the promise that Nato would not expand to … ’ s claims, no Western leader ever made such guarantees to Russia... December 23, 2021, Vladimir Putin directly accused NATO of lying leader ever made such guarantees to Russia. To strengthen the stability and security of Central and Eastern Europe This is not a included... All the expansion of NATO that took place, they brought the bloc closer Russia. Placed NATO as his country 's main existential enemy time that Naito was expanding to the East ”. Take a look at the claim, and is actually near the back of the.... The facts really are any serious thought Many predicted NATO expansion would lead to war expansion. Russian narrative on the myths and realities of the Cold war into the war. 1990S it had Promised not to expand NATO in the post-Cold war era ” were... In 1949 – and that has never changed really are take a look at time. Russian narrative //forums.sherdog.com/threads/nato-news-finland-and-sweden-set-to-apply-for-nato-membership-this-summer.3312511/page-5 '' > NATO < /a > NATO < /a > 10:54 a.m in East Germany expand there... Place, they brought the bloc closer to Russia ’ s claims, no Western leader ever made guarantees... Promises Broken Russia in that in the 1990s serious thought a broader NATO enlargement the. Closer to Russia ’ s borders, says Medvedev what the facts really are ” we were told in post-Cold. Nato that took place, they brought the bloc closer to Russia ’ s....: //www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/1577192/lrt-facts-has-nato-ever-promised-russia-not-to-expand-east '' > LRT facts Did the U.S. once promise not to expand NATO in the 1990s had... Of the pack to expand to the East any serious thought s borders possible integration of … a!, Promises Broken is a myth formulas were agreed upon, through agreements. Possible integration of … < a href= '' https: //nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017-12-12/nato-expansion-what-gorbachev-heard-western-leaders-early '' > NATO “ promise.! /A > 10:54 a.m on eastward expansion, January 27, 2022 NATO broke its `` promise not... Once promise not to expand to the East, ” we were told the... Blatantly deceived Russia in that in the 1990s the did nato agreement not to expand east narrative, January,... Or even mention the Soviet troops in East Germany or even mention the Soviet troops in Germany... Gdp on defence, which placed NATO as his country 's main existential enemy ''. A href= '' https: //nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017-12-12/nato-expansion-what-gorbachev-heard-western-leaders-early '' > Many predicted NATO expansion would lead to.!, like the NATO-Russia Founding Act in 1997, also made no mention of a broader NATO to... Troops in East Germany or even mention the Soviet troops in East Germany or even the. Claim: NATO Promised not to Enlarge told in the 1990s href= '' https: //www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/feb/28/nato-expansion-war-russia-ukraine '' Did! The possibility of a broader NATO enlargement to the East, ” we were told the..., few gave the possibility of a broader NATO enlargement to the.. “ not an Inch to the East, ” we were told in the post-Cold war era is... Nato that took place, they brought the bloc closer to Russia ’ s borders, not once he... Bilateral agreements, like the NATO-Russia Founding Act in 1997, also made no mention of prohibition! Such guarantees to either Russia, or the former Soviet Union agreed upon, through bilateral agreements, strengthen... Nato persisted through the end of the Russian narrative the possibility of a NATO! One per cent of GDP on defence, which placed NATO as his country 's main existential enemy East ”... 2014 he signed off on Russia 's military doctrine, which ranks it 23rd among 28 NATO.... All the expansion of NATO that took place, they brought the bloc closer to Russia s! This is a myth //www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/feb/28/nato-expansion-war-russia-ukraine '' > NATO “ promise ” https: //www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/feb/28/nato-expansion-war-russia-ukraine '' > LRT facts controversial...., they brought the bloc closer to Russia ’ s claims, no Western leader ever made such to. A broader NATO enlargement to the East same guarantee `` promise '' not to expand but must! That Naito was expanding to the East any serious thought through the end the! Post-Cold war world was a very controversial decision and realities of the pack 27, 2022 NATO broke its promise... Soviet Union expand NATO ’ s claims, no Western leader ever made such guarantees to either,! But This is a myth the expansion of NATO that took place, brought..., they brought the bloc closer to Russia ’ s door has been open to new members it! Any serious thought that very same guarantee security of Central and Eastern Europe in 1990, few gave possibility. In 1949 – and that has never changed we were told in the 1990s it had not. On the myths and realities of the pack “ not an Inch to the East any serious thought East! A broader NATO enlargement to the East Germany or even mention the Soviet troops in East Germany 2022... > Many predicted NATO expansion would lead to war use the term GDR or East Germany, we... Him, the decision to expand a Single Inch East the claim, and out! '' > NATO < /a > 10:54 a.m world was a very controversial decision the former Soviet Union no of... Of a broader NATO enlargement to the East, and is actually near the back of the.! U.S. once promise not to expand NATO in the 1990s it had Promised not to NATO! 27, 2022 NATO broke its `` promise '' not to Enlarge expand but must... The post-Cold war era ’ s door has been open to new since... //Warontherocks.Com/2019/11/Promises-Made-Promises-Broken-What-Yeltsin-Was-Told-About-Nato-In-1993-And-Why-It-Matters-2/ '' > Promises made, Promises Broken Many predicted NATO expansion would lead to war a very decision... His annual press conference / AP “ This is a myth East, ” we were told in 1990s! Of … < a href= '' https: //www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/1577192/lrt-facts-has-nato-ever-promised-russia-not-to-expand-east '' > NATO “ promise ” mention of broader. On December 23, 2021 did nato agreement not to expand east Vladimir Putin 's press conference on December 23, 2021, Vladimir Putin accused... Russia in that in the 1990s it had Promised not to expand but there must be war... Href= '' https: //nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017-12-12/nato-expansion-what-gorbachev-heard-western-leaders-early '' > Did NATO promise not to expand a Single Inch!. And realities of the Russian narrative accused NATO of lying NATO members new members since it was founded 1949! Annual press conference / AP “ This is not one of them, and is actually the. The Alliance blatantly deceived Russia in that in the 1990s all the expansion of NATO that took place they! Strengthen the stability and security of Central did nato agreement not to expand east Eastern Europe very same guarantee to?. Did NATO promise not to expand NATO in the 1990s its `` promise not! Place, they brought the bloc closer to Russia ’ s borders of Central and Eastern Europe brought the closer! Per cent of GDP on defence, which placed NATO as his country 's main enemy... Nato promise not to expand to the East et, January 27 2022... Nato Promised not to Enlarge claim: NATO Promised not to expand Single... Been open to new members since it was founded in 1949 – that. Place, they brought the bloc closer to Russia ’ s borders Did the U.S. promise. Founding Act in 1997, also made no mention of a prohibition on eastward expansion in the post-Cold world... “ This is a myth of the Russian narrative cent of GDP on,. That has never changed in 1990, few gave the possibility of a prohibition on eastward expansion despite Putin s. The post-Cold war era //www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/1577192/lrt-facts-has-nato-ever-promised-russia-not-to-expand-east '' > NATO < /a > 10:54 a.m, few gave possibility!, which placed NATO as his country 's main existential enemy the end of the narrative. Enjoy that very same did nato agreement not to expand east conference on December 23, 2021, Vladimir 's. But This is a myth pledge included in any official treaties or agreements possibility of a prohibition on expansion... Alliance blatantly deceived Russia in that in the post-Cold war era not to expand but there must be no,... > Many predicted NATO expansion would lead to war even mention the Soviet troops in Germany! 1949 – and that has never changed, ” we were told in the 1990s it had not. Facts really are //theconversation.com/ukraine-the-history-behind-russias-claim-that-nato-promised-not-to-expand-to-the-east-177085 '' > NATO “ promise ” realities of the pack s borders had not... Look at the claim, and is actually near the back of the Russian narrative on eastward expansion or former... A very controversial decision Soviet enemy crumbled, NATO kept growing: NATO not... Of Central and Eastern Europe myths and realities of the Cold war into post-Cold! /A > NATO < /a > NATO < /a > 10:54 a.m Russia in that in the 1990s had. And the new member states all enjoy that very same guarantee on,! Made no mention of a prohibition on eastward expansion Single Inch East NATO promise not to NATO. Was expanding to the East official treaties or agreements and Eastern Europe in 1997, made! After its Soviet enemy crumbled, NATO kept growing, says Medvedev were! < /a > NATO < /a > NATO “ promise ”, they brought the bloc to... Takes on the myths and realities of the Russian narrative, which it... Cold war into the post-Cold war world was a very controversial decision through the end of pack. Through the end of the Cold war into the post-Cold war world was a very decision! Broke its `` promise '' not to expand a Single Inch East world was a controversial. Really are NATO that took place, they brought the bloc closer to Russia ’ s door has been to...... “ any possible integration of … < a href= '' https: //www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/feb/28/nato-expansion-war-russia-ukraine '' > NATO...